GREATER TORONTO AREA / SCHOOL GUIDES

Top 10 Catholic secondary schools in the GTA

Compare ten Catholic high schools selected from 99 rated GTA schools. Explore dated results, specialist and French-language programs, regional guides and all schools tied at the cutoff.

The Fraser Institute score measures selected academic indicators. It is one starting point for research, not a complete assessment of teaching, student support, wellbeing or school fit.

Equal scores share competition rank: one plus the number of schools scoring higher. Each list links ten canonical regional profiles. Ties are ordered alphabetically by current common school name, ignoring the French École prefix; every equally scored school outside the tenth-place cutoff is disclosed and linked. A tied school outside the displayed ten is not ranked lower.

List coverage. This comparison uses dated academic indicators. It does not measure overall school quality, determine attendance boundaries or guarantee admission to any school or program.

How we compiled this list
  1. GTA rank01

    Markham · York Region · English

    St. Augustine Catholic High School

    York Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12

    10.0 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  2. GTA rank01

    Toronto · English

    St. Michael’s Choir School — Secondary

    Toronto Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12 (full school: Grades 3–12)

    10.0 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  3. GTA rank01

    Thornhill · Markham · York Region · English

    St. Robert Catholic High School

    York Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12

    10.0 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  4. GTA rank01

    Richmond Hill · York Region · English

    St. Theresa of Lisieux Catholic High School

    York Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12

    10.0 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  5. GTA rank05

    Willowdale · Toronto · English

    Cardinal Carter Academy for the Arts

    Toronto Catholic District School Board

    Grades 7–12 (secondary section: Grades 9–12)

    9.3 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  6. GTA rank06

    Etobicoke · Toronto · English

    Bishop Allen Academy

    Toronto Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12

    8.7 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  7. GTA rank07

    Etobicoke · Toronto · English

    Father John Redmond Catholic Secondary School and Regional Arts Centre

    Toronto Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12

    8.6 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  8. GTA rank08

    Markham · York Region · English

    Father Michael McGivney Catholic Academy

    York Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12

    8.5 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  9. GTA rank09

    Oakville · Halton Region · French

    École secondaire catholique Sainte-Trinité

    Conseil scolaire catholique MonAvenir

    Grades 7–12

    8.3 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide
  10. GTA rank10

    Milton · Halton Region · English

    Bishop P. F. Reding Catholic Secondary School

    Halton Catholic District School Board

    Grades 9–12

    8.2 / 10Fraser academic score · tied scores share a GTA rankSchool guide

Equal scores at the cutoff.

The following schools have the same 8.2 academic score as the last school displayed above. Alphabetical order is the sole tie-break for the ten places in this list; exclusion does not imply a lower rating.

UNDERSTAND THE COMPARISON

How the GTA school lists are selected

These lists compare the 2025 Fraser Institute Ontario reports, which measure 2023/2024 academic results. Elementary and secondary results remain separate and explicitly dated. They are not current-year test scores or measures of every aspect of school quality.

The Fraser Institute score measures selected academic indicators. It is one starting point for research, not a complete assessment of teaching, student support, wellbeing or school fit.

Coverage. The full census covers 1,434 rated public and Catholic records in Toronto, Durham, York, Peel and Halton, including French-language schools. All 3,799 Ontario app-record coordinates were checked against official provincial municipal polygons; 1,451 records fell inside the GTA, and 17 private records were excluded. Only schools with published report scores are eligible. Administrative or virtual school addresses can appear in the report census.

Ties. Equal scores share competition rank: one plus the number of schools scoring higher. Each list links ten canonical regional profiles. Ties are ordered alphabetically by current common school name, ignoring the French École prefix; every equally scored school outside the tenth-place cutoff is disclosed and linked. A tied school outside the displayed ten is not ranked lower.

Read the ranking methodology

Methodology source checked October 3, 2026.

Use the board’s current boundary and registration information, visit the school and discuss your child’s needs before making a school or home decision.

Prepared by Offplan Canada using AI-assisted research and source checks. How we prepare these guides · About Offplan Canada. School and institution names identify sources; they do not imply endorsement.